I feel kind of the same about this scenario as i do about the star wars originals vs. I just finished the fellowship and i was blown away, the adventure was amazing. In which order should one watch lotr and the hobbit. My biggest problem, however, with the hobbit trilogy is its use of spoilers and foreshadowing. In what order should i read the entire lord of the rings series. Should a new viewer watch the hobbit movies first or the. You dont really neeeed to read the hobbit in order to understand what lord of the rings is about. The lord of the rings order starts with the fellowship of the ring, and ends with the return of the king. Arwens father, lord elrond, holds a council that decides the ring must be. One of these is expertly immersing you in the world of middle earth. The original lotr trilogy was far better than the hobbit. Okay, so im planning on reading the lord of the rings series. If you pack in too much before then, they just become monotonous, and it lessons their menace in the audiences mind.
A rainy weekend spent watching the greatest film trilogy ever made is a. The movies themselves are bluray, but the extra features are dvd discs, by design, which is ok. Before i posted this, i had already purchased the theatrical edition of the trilogy, i will have to check out the ee at a later date. Which movie should i watch first, the hobbit or the lord. I would like to see the hobbit but was wondering if we should see the lord of the rings first or can that wait. The hobbit is the prequel to the lord of the rings trilogy. What movie should you watch first the hobbit or lord of.
Originally based on a book, this unique movie series has gone on to be the most watched trilogy in the world. If you do, itll make the lotr series seem a lot more mysterious and make your mind go. Tolkien, with large portions of the trilogy inspired by the appendices to the return of the king, which expand on the story told in the hobbit, as well as new material and characters written especially for the films. Personally, i tried reading the hobbit, but it was so boring to me. Feb 28, 2014 you dont have to watch any of the hobbit movies to understand lord of the rings. Should we see the lord of the rings trilogy before the hobbit. I read the hobbit a long, long time ago, and now i really want to read it again. They can be a source of amazing new material for fans but can also.
The musics bring the scenes from the movie whenever they are played. The first lotr movie came out in 2001, and millions of people saw it and liked it without knowing anything about the hobbit. Im about to watch the lord of the rings trilogy reddit. Produced and distributed by new line cinema with the coproduction of wingnut films, it is an international venture between new. And yes, there is a book called fellowship of the ring unlike what some have said. Should i watch the hobbit movies first after reading the book or read. The hobbit, or there and back again should i read this.
In all honesty, you shouldnt exactly start with lotr. It doesnt play a critical role in the understanding of the trilogy. I saw the lord of the rings trilogy when they first came out and have been in love ever since. You should really start with the hobbit trilogy first. Tolkiens trilogy that tells the saga of the hobbits of middleearth and the great war of the rings. Unlike the lord of the rings, the hobbit isnt part of a trilogy. The fellowship of the ring the lord of the rings, book 1. I havent read the books, but i am planning to as soon as i can get my hands on some copies. Set in the fictional world of middleearth, the films follow the hobbit frodo. In addition, there is a message of environment over the needs of industry which had become even more resonate in the decades since the books have been released. In what order should i watch the lord of the rings. The lord of the rings trilogy the trilogy tells a story of a meek hobbit of the.
The hobbit is told as a flashback by old bilbo recording his journey and while preparations are on going for his 111 th. The author slowly pieces together the world by having characters not explain things to the reader, but instead to other characters. I would watch the hobbit first, because its an easier getting into it trilogy, while the lord of the rings is a lot heavier. The lord of the rings is a film series of three epic fantasy adventure films directed by peter. We are in the middle of reading the harry potter series and dont want to dive into another magic series before we have finished the books and watched those movies. My family and i havent seen the lord of the rings trilogy because my children were too young before now. Is it necessary to read the hobbit before the lord of the rings. Although both books had challenges and death along the way, the hobbit was more contained in its stakes, while the lord of the. The hobbit trilogy bilbo baggins is swept up into an epic quest to reclaim the lost. An unexpected journey 2012 follows the adventures of hobbit bilbo baggins martin freeman, who, at the instigation of the wizard gandalf ian mckellen. For all things tolkien, lord of the rings, and the hobbit. Starting with the hobbit, it gets more and more sad, while starting with the lord of the rings leaves you with a happy felling at the end of it all. The lord of the rings was also much darker in tone than the hobbit.
However, if you would prefer a smaller filesize, you can also download the. It sets up the trilogy that follows and introduces you to most of the major characters. The decadeslong development of the silmarillion had some to do with. You can download the lord of the rings books format. Lord of the rings trilogy soundtrack is one of the best epic motion picture soundtracks ever created. Bingewatching the lord of the rings trilogy over the. The hobbit takes place before the lord of the rings.
The hobbit trilogy and the lord of the rings trilogy. Should one read the hobbit before reading the lord of the. The hobbit trilogy and the lord of the rings trilogy bluray at. Well, heres an easy way to annoy a whole load of tolkien fans. From the lord of the rings, the hobbit and harry potter to batman v superman. So, does the hobbit take place before lotr, or after. Peter jacksons hobbit trilogy recut into a single 4hour film. The trilogy tells the story of a meek hobbit of the shire and eight companions setting out on a journey to mount doom to destroy the one ring and the dark lord sauron. The fellowship of the ring, the two towers, and the return of the king. Peter jacksons the lords of the rings lotr and the hobbit movie trilogies have been great commercial successes. My wife and i like the open world of the hobbit game are any other game in the lego franchise like that game as well.
Not everyone has an enormous tv, but you should try to watch on. The hobbit was not part of the initial lord of the rings saga. Once the two hobbits make it to rivendell, it becomes pretty obvious that the ring must be taken to mordor, to be destroyed in the fire where it was made. An unexpected journey are set 60 years before what happens in the lord of the rings trilogy, but just because its an origin story doesnt. The trilogy tells the story of a meek hobbit of the shire and eight. Tolkien, is a book that excels in a number of things. Id recommend eating breakfast or a light snack before you start, then. I was wondering whether i should read the hobbit first or should. The average reader reads between 200 and 250 words per minute.
I have had it read it to me, i just dont remember it. If the hobbit has around 95,000 words, then it would take the average reader between around 6 and 8 hours to read it, whereas the film trilogy would take around 8 and a half hours to watch, if the third movies runtime is on track with the first two. I have no previous experience with lord of the rings. Many people consider the lord of the rings to be the best trilogy ever made. May 26, 2018 bingewatching the lord of the rings trilogy over the course of a rainy weekend is a rite of passage. The hobbit, but really, you should read the silmarillion. The hobbit, or there and back again should i start with the. The fellowship of the ring, the first book of the lord of the rings series by j.
Sooo on another answer i went ahead and did an entire chronological experience of tolkiens world mainly cinema but also including games and fan movies for a. I tried to get a refund or credit for it before i buy the bundle, but could not. May 27, 2012 the hobbit is not a prequel, it is a separate story completely, which occurs many years before the events in lord of the rings, so it would not spoil any storyline if you watch it first. Dec 02, 2014 over the last decade and a half, jackson has adapted the hobbit and the lord of the rings into two movie trilogies, delighting millions of fans in the process. The lord of the rings is a film series of three epic fantasy adventure films directed by peter jackson, based on the novel written by j.
The lord of the rings trilogy took the fantasy genre and redefined it in a literate way that the rest of fantasy has been attempting to catch up to ever since. Dec 14, 2012 the events depicted in peter jacksons the hobbit. Yes, the lotr trilogy came out a decade before the hobbit films, but i wish they had respected the order in which the books came out. The lord of the rings trilogy tells the story of frodo baggins elijah wood. The hobbit is in essence a prequel to the entire story. It is book one of the trilogy the lord of the rings. The tolkien edit peter jacksons hobbit trilogy recut. All three films from director peter jacksons blockbuster prequel to the lord of the rings trilogy. I think you and your friends should start with the classic trilogy before moving on to the hobbit. The best way to read tolkiens hobbit and lord of the. I do know people who never read lotr because they were so disgusted by the very first sentence, which. The return of the king is the towering climax to j.
May 31, 2010 yes you should, there are specific details left out of the lord of the rings, such as the finding of the ring by bilbo baggins. Jun 24, 2019 my biggest problem, however, with the hobbit trilogy is its use of spoilers and foreshadowing. But when i read the series, i decided to start with the hobbit because the events in it takes place 60 years before the events in the lord of the rings. What happened in moria before the lord of the rings. Tolkien, the world of middleearth has captured the imaginations of readers and been the setting for some of the worlds best loved. Lego batman 2 and 3, lego marvel superheroes and avengers, lego jurassic world.
The films are subtitled the fellowship of the ring 2001, the two towers 2002 and the return of the king 2003. Feb 16, 2015 side by side comparison where the hobbit shows his quality as a terrible trilogy. The hobbit is a film series consisting of three high fantasy adventure films directed by peter jackson. Bonus content from the hobbit trilogy theatrical and extended editions will be. The hobbit is short enough to read in a single night, contains all the best bits of lord of the rings i. Even before you start to devour the bonus footage, theres some. The trilogy tells a continuous story set in middleearth 60 years before the.
Set in middleearth 60 years before events in the lord of the rings, the hobbit. It gives a lot of useful background information, but you can go ahead and read the lord of the rings first if you want to. This is the way to watch the lord of the rings series sfcritic. I just finished the hobbit, and damn, what an awesome book. If you want the order to read them in, i would say, the hobbit, then the lord of the rings, and then the silmarillion. It isnt essential reading the hobbit before the lotr trilogy, but tolkien wrote it before the lotr and i think its interesting to see, read, the growth the author made, how he changed or, more correct, developed his wonderful world that is represented in his book. The main character in lotr is actually the very young cousin of the title character in the hobbit. Are the lord of the rings and the hobbit movies connected. This order solves the largest issue facing chronological story order. The hobbit trilogy and the lord of the rings trilogy bluray. It is designed to be read after, and will make more sense with the hobbit s backstory. Middleearth extended editions 6film collection movies on. Finishing the lord of the rings led to further changes which were eventually rolled into the silmarillion, even though that book is largely concerned with events that precede the hobbit and the lord of the rings and it was drafted before both novels were written. However, if youve not watched any part of the trilogy, its recommended you start with it in order to have a better understanding.
1615 683 128 325 801 786 987 307 1690 766 657 1306 1189 280 726 1529 1150 214 902 1020 1114 759 1522 538 1627 563 104 116 2 1100 1526 705 376 1012 526 1198 1440 20 1290 1356 724 778 693 135 341 545 295